Yes, you can still file and deposit your own payroll taxes with payroll software, but only if your provider offers a basic or self-file plan. Some providers now require tax filing on every plan. Look for plans labeled “Basic,” “Self-file,” or “No tax filing,” such as Patriot Software’s Basic Payroll.
Why some employers prefer to file their own payroll taxes
Many business owners like the convenience of handing off payroll tax calculations, filings, and deposits to their full-service payroll provider.
But plenty of employers would rather do the tax filings and deposits themselves. Common reasons include:
- Control over cash flow: When you make tax deposits, you decide when the money leaves your bank account (but be sure to follow your IRS deposit schedule).
- Save money: Payroll software that only calculates payroll is typically less expensive than payroll services that also deposit and file taxes.
- Your accountant handles deposits and filings: You don’t need your payroll system to file and deposit taxes if you have an accountant who already does it.
Payroll software vs. payroll service: Which one handles tax filing?
The type of payroll product you use (DIY software or service) generally indicates whether you can file your own payroll taxes.
Payroll software calculates wages, withholding, and employer taxes; creates pay stubs; and pays employees with direct deposit or paychecks. From there, you deposit the taxes and file the forms. Payroll software without tax filing and deposits might be called “Basic,” “No tax filing,” or “Self-file.”
Full-service payroll services do the same calculations, then deposit and file federal, state, and local payroll taxes for you.
Here’s a quick chart showing detailed differences between DIY payroll software and full-service payroll services:
| Features | Payroll Software (Self-File) | Full-Service Payroll |
|---|---|---|
| Calculates wages and withholding | Yes | Yes |
| Pay employees with direct deposit | Yes | Yes |
| Deposits federal, state, and local taxes | No | Yes |
| Files Forms 941 and 940 | No | Yes |
| Files Forms W-2 and W-3 | No | Yes |
Basic payroll software that lets you file and deposit is typically best for owners who want control or who have an accountant handle filings and deposits.
Full-service payroll software is typically best for busy owners who don’t want to handle tax filings and deposits or risk filing mistakes.
Not all online payroll platforms offer both options. However, Patriot Software does. You can choose between Basic Payroll (you file and deposit) and Full Service Payroll (federal, state, and local taxes handled).
Full service or do it yourself? How to decide
Deciding between full-service and DIY payroll is a personal preference. But most small businesses do better with full-service payroll if they have employees in more than one state or no one to handle deposit deadlines. Doing payroll yourself works if you have the time, a simple setup, and a steady routine.
Here’s how the two options compare for 1, 5, and 10 employees.
1. What each option costs
These are example prices using Patriot Software’s pricing. Your costs will vary by provider, plan, and number of workers paid.
| Employees Paid | Basic Payroll (you file and deposit) | Full Service Payroll (Patriot Software files and deposits) |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | $21 per month | $42 per month |
| 5 | $37 per month | $62 per month |
| 10 | $57 per month | $87 per month |
Example math: Basic Payroll is $17 per month plus $4 per worker paid. Full Service Payroll is $37 per month plus $5 per worker paid. Prices are before any promotions.
Software that only calculates payroll costs less. But the savings come with a trade-off. You take on the deposits, the filings, and the deadlines.
2. How much time does filing yourself take?
If you opt for a basic option without tax filing, plan for:
- Making federal tax deposits
- Filing Form 941 quarterly, plus any state and local filings
- Filing Forms W-2 and W-3 annually, along with Form 940
- Making any state and local tax deposits
Basic payroll options should include reports with the information you need to speed up tax filings and deposits. But, consider giving yourself about an hour per filing responsibility when you get started.
3. What happens if you miss a deadline?
The IRS charges penalties when employers deposit late or file late. Here are the federal ranges.
| Penalty | How It Works |
|---|---|
| Failure to deposit | 2% of the unpaid deposit if 1 to 5 days late |
| Failure to deposit | 5% if 6 to 15 days late |
| Failure to deposit | 10% if more than 15 days late |
| Failure to deposit | 15% if still unpaid more than 10 days after the IRS sends a notice |
| Failure to file (Form 941) | 5% of the unpaid tax for each month or part of a month, up to 25% |
The deposit penalties don’t add up. The higher rate replaces the lower one. Interest can also apply, and your state may charge its own penalties. Source: IRS Failure to Deposit Penalty and Patriot Software’s failure-to-file penalty guide.
4. Who should choose which
Full service payroll fits you if:
- You have employees in more than one state.
- No one on your team wants to track deposit deadlines.
- You want your provider to file and deposit your payroll taxes.
- You’d rather spend your time running the business.
- You don’t have an accountant who handles filings.
Doing it yourself fits you if:
- You have a small team and a single-state setup.
- You want control over when tax money leaves your bank account.
- You or your accountant already handle deposits and filings.
- You’re comfortable following your IRS deposit schedule.
- You want the lowest monthly software cost.
Not sure yet? You can start with Basic Payroll and switch later. With Patriot Software, you can choose Basic Payroll or Full Service Payroll. Try either one free for 30 days.
I want to file myself. What are my responsibilities?
When you handle your own payroll taxes, your software gives you the numbers. It should include easy-to-generate payroll reports that show you exactly how much you paid and withheld.
From there, you’re responsible for getting the money and forms to the right agencies on time. If you make a mistake, you’re accountable.
Heads up: penalties for late deposits or filings can add up. The IRS charges a failure-to-deposit penalty that ranges from 2% – 15% and a failure-to-file penalty of 5% – 25%.
Don’t want to risk it? Some payroll services provide a tax filing reliability guarantee to cover penalties and interest if if tax deposits or filings are inaccurate or late.
Here’s an overview of your responsibilities:
Federal tax deposits
If you use a basic payroll software without tax filing, you must deposit the following:
- Federal income tax
- Social Security tax
- Medicare tax
- FUTA tax (federal unemployment tax)
Federal forms
Unless you use full-service payroll, you are responsible for filing Forms:
| Form | Use | Filing Frequency |
|---|---|---|
| 941 | To report federal income, Social Security, and Medicare taxes. | Quarterly |
| 944 | Alternative to 941 that’s only used if the IRS notifies you to file it (generally employers with $1,000 or less in annual employment tax liability). | Annually |
| 940 | To report FUTA tax. | Annually |
| W-2 and W-3 | To report an employee’s annual wages and taxes withheld. | Annually |
| 1099-NEC | To report a contractor’s payment of $2,000 or more during the year (beginning in 2026). | Annually |
State and local taxes
Most states require you to deposit state income tax withholding and SUTA (state unemployment) tax and file state returns. There may also be state-specific taxes such as paid family and medical leave (PFML) or transit taxes. Some cities, counties, and school districts have their own payroll taxes.
Due dates and forms vary by location.
Questions to ask when choosing payroll software
If you have questions about tax filing and depositing, ask the following questions:
- Is tax filing included in every plan, or is it optional?
- Can I turn off automatic tax payments?
- When is tax money withdrawn?
- If I handle tax deposits and filings myself, what reports will I get to help me?
- Can I change plans later?
You can typically find the answers to these questions on a payroll platform’s website (e.g., FAQs). Or, you can contact them directly.
Can you still file your own payroll taxes? The bottom line
You can still file and deposit your own payroll taxes if you use software, but it depends on what software provider you use.
Before signing up, check whether tax filing is optional and whether you can turn off automatic payments.
With Patriot Software, the choice is yours
At Patriot Software, you can sign up for Basic Payroll or Full Service Payroll. You choose the plan that best suits your preferences.
- Basic Payroll: Run payroll and handle payroll taxes yourself. Our software calculates wages and taxes, and you can use payroll reports to easily see what you owe. Free direct deposit, Auto Payroll, free employee portal, health benefit integration, and other must-have features are included.
- Full Service Payroll: Everything in Basic Payroll, plus we deposit federal, state, and local payroll taxes and file required forms for you.
Frequently asked questions
Yes, you can file your own payroll taxes if your software provider offers a plan without tax filing. Basic payroll software calculates wages and taxes and provides reports you can reference when depositing taxes and filing the forms yourself. Patriot Software offers both a self-file plan (Basic Payroll) and a full-service plan.
Payroll software calculates payroll and typically has all the features of a payroll service except for automatic tax filings and deposits. Full-service payroll files and deposits federal, state, and local payroll taxes.
If you opt for a self-filing option, you are responsible for filing Forms 941 or 944, 940, W-2 and W-3, and 1099-NEC (if applicable), plus any applicable state or local payroll tax filings.
Yes, it’s usually less expensive to use a basic payroll option that lets you file and deposit taxes on your own. But, the cost of having a full-service payroll solution can be as little as $20 extra per month. In terms of time savings, that may be worth it to a busy business owner. Decide which plan is best for your business.
Typically, yes, you can switch from self-filing taxes to full-service payroll (or vice versa) as long as your provider has both options.
It depends on your time, your team size, and where your employees work. Full service payroll costs more each month, but your provider handles deposits and filings. Doing it yourself costs less, but you own every deadline and any penalties.
Prices vary by provider. As an example, Patriot Software’s Full Service Payroll is $37 per month plus $5 per worker paid. That’s $42 per month for 1 employee and $87 per month for 10, before promotions.
Yes, if your provider offers a basic or self-file plan. Patriot Software’s Basic Payroll calculates your taxes, and you deposit and file them yourself.
This article has been updated from its original publication date of October 9, 2026.
This is not intended as legal advice; for more information, please click here.


